On Nov. 17, peace activists Aziz Abu Sarah and Maoz Inon visited EMU to discuss their book, “The Future is Peace.” It documents the collective journey of two Israeli and Palestinian peace activists, Inon who lost his parents in the Oct. 7 attacks, and Sarah whose brother died after being tortured in an Israeli prison. They have now made the decision to choose peace over revenge, and to oppose violence as a solution in the region.
I have not fully read the book, so I do not claim to understand their entire framework. However, I have been concerned by some of their talking points, specifically the idea that values should be the basis of addressing Israel-Palestine rather than looking at particular colonial policy. I have also been concerned by the kind of discussion they foster, which is often very abstract and unspecific in terms of solutions.
This review from Brian Eno captures the kind of sentiment which pops up regularly:
If there is ever to be a sustainable settlement in the Middle East, it will come not from bombs and bogus peace boards but from ordinary people coming to respect each other and tolerate each other’s differences – and even finally to enjoy them. This moving book shows the essential first step on that path, as two courageous men stop hating each other and start talking together.
Many of us hear language like this – specifically phrases like “tolerating each other’s differences,” and assume that the message must automatically be good. But stripped back into plain language, Eno is basically saying that progress will not come from violence or diplomacy, structural policy or resistance; it will come from Israeli settlers and Palestinian civilians coming to respect each other and tolerate each other’s differences, sharing perspectives and stories. I have a hard time taking this seriously.
The fundamental problems in Israel and Palestine are not abstract ones of love and hate, but structural ones of physical violence and colonial economic policy. Workshops and peace discussions do not stop the Israeli military as they murder more and more Palestinian children. Much more than just “hate,” the problems in Palestine are things such as this: according to the British Medical Association, as of 2025, 94% of hospitals in Gaza have been damaged or destroyed. The estimated life expectancy in Gaza in 2024 fell to 40.4 years, according to a 2025 study by Max Planck Institute for Demographic Research and the Centre for Demographic Studies. According to the United Nations, 1.9 million Palestinians in the Gaza Strip have been displaced, and according to Al Jazeera in 2026, the ongoing genocide has already killed 1 out of every 30 people in Gaza.
Some of the primary colonial structures Israel uses to undermine Palestine are as follows: directly attacking its economic independence through Military Orders, blocking its access to Israeli and external markets by surrounding its territory entirely, cutting off trade routes, controlling its natural resources through strategic land expropriation, Balkanizing it into disconnected territories and blocking trade and movement between them, and controlling its tax revenues which compose a major part of the Palestinian Authority’s budget for political leverage. Everyday Palestinians have to navigate these structures consistently, and they all represent not only a problem of violence or non-violence, but of economy and geography – and it becomes immediately clear that if the land problem is not addressed, all these issues will persist.
In order for Palestine to truly prosper as an independent state, it needs not just the formal recognition of statehood, but at the very least, the guarantee of all of these things: regaining full control of their borders, control of their own trade and tax revenue, the right of return to Palestinian refugees displaced through colonialism, uniting the fragmented territories of the West Bank, rebuilding Gaza, and ending the occupation.
The absence of fighting is not the absence of colonialism, and so Palestine needs far more than a ceasefire. According to Martin Luther King Jr. himself, “True peace is not merely the absence of some negative force – tension, confusion or war; it is the presence of some positive force – justice, good will and brotherhood.”
Therefore, peeled back behind all the sentimental poetry practiced by utopians dreaming of a better tomorrow, unless they design specific ways to materially oppose Zionist colonial policy, their discourse only serves the interests of the status quo – the interests of Israel.
The liberal tries to become an arbitrator, but he is incapable of solving the problems… The liberal is so preoccupied with stopping confrontation that he usually finds himself defending and calling for law and order, the law and order of the oppressor… the politics of the liberal leads him into a position where he finds himself politically aligned with the oppressor rather than with the oppressed. (The Pitfalls of Liberalism, Ture, 1969)
During the Q&A portion of the EMU event, I asked Inon and Sarah a series of very specific questions around their positions on specific solutions like the two-state solution, checkpoint system, etc. Sarah answered me by saying that they approach the political solution from the perspective of values rather than specific policy, and went on to list major values such as equality, dignity, security, safety, and more. He talked about establishing negotiation rooms to discuss the specific issues I had raised, and then started talking about how gender-equal discussions tend to be better. He did not take a position on any of the questions I asked, but returned back to a general set of talking points which told me very little new information.
We do not build societies from morality, we build them from land and labor. Addressing a conflict is therefore not primarily about values, it is about material structures and relations. Hate will always be an inseparable part of a settler colonial society – it is inherent to it. We can only properly address that hate by dismantling colonialism itself.
The problem is not violence and hate, and so the solution is not peace and love. The problem is Israeli colonialism, and the solution is Palestinian decolonial liberation.
The future is not peace. The Future is Liberation.
