1

I have always had an issue with the concept of the butterfly effect. It isn’t that I don’t believe in its legitimacy as a theory; I just don’t like its implications for my life. I don’t want to believe that I was one small choice away from being a radically different person. I especially do not like thinking that one of those life-altering choices was one of my own. I find comfort in the idea that I was never at risk of being anyone other than myself. Yet still, as always, life is uncomfortable.

In the spring of my sophomore year, I saw an email about the Co-Editor-in-Chief position. At the time, I knew nothing about newspapers and thought the email was just asking for writers. I responded (well past the deadline) and said I was interested. By the time I realized that the job description went a bit past writing articles, it was too late. Now, I regularly spend ten hours in the basement of Maplewood editing and publishing a newspaper that I care too deeply about to admit publicly. 

At times, it feels like most aspects of my life and my character were decided by chance rather than choice. Many love this randomness of life. They affectionately call it serendipity. I can’t stand it. My friends think I have an issue with control… maybe. Regardless, I have searched for a more satisfying explanation of life.

Jean-Paul Sartre said that, for humans, existence precedes essence. When you make a chair, for example, the essence comes first. You have an idea of what the chair is going to be before ever making it. For humans, we first exist. We are born; then, through every choice we make, we define our own essence. 

Last weekend, I ran my last cross-country race ever. An eight-year chapter of my life finished. A random Saturday in Charlottesville, no fanfare, no ceremony, just quietly ended as I crossed the line one last time. I began running cross country on a whim. In eighth grade at track tryouts, my friend convinced me to run the mile. I was there to try out for sprints; I had never run a mile before. I gave it a shot. Now I’m finding time in between assignments to look for graduate assistant coaching positions, with the ultimate goal of becoming a head cross country coach.

I like to think of myself as a very intentional person. I try to put deep thought into my decisions when I can. I often select my words like a politician carefully walking party lines. My image has been meticulously curated, and yet, in reality, so much of it happened by chance.

So what is it? Do we get to define our own essence through a series of actions? Or are our lives determined by a cosmic game of roulette that can be altered by a single flap of a butterfly’s wings? 

I think it’s true that aspects of our personality – our interests, hobbies, friends, etc. – are essentially chosen for us, products of our circumstances. But these are not what define us; they are all surface level. Humans are so much deeper than that. Sartre might describe it as essence, religion might call it soul, others might say spirit; regardless of what you might call it, humans are not merely a compilation of interests.

There is a less tangible aspect of the individual. It is hidden away, buried in complexity. It can only be understood through deep, prolonged, intentional observation, and even then it cannot be fully grasped. This is why we lock on to the more tangible “personality.” It is much easier to understand and categorize. However, in my opinion, it is much more rewarding to go through the process of understanding your own and others’ less tangible self. 

This form of the self is revealed through actions. It is forged by a series of decisions made throughout our entire lives. Each choice is either an affirmation of who you are or a step in the direction of who you are becoming. 

Co-Editor

More From Opinion

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *